Judge Sides With Coyote Springs Developers in Nevada Water Rights Fight; Jury Could Award Up to $600 Million

Judge Sides With Coyote Springs Developers in Nevada Water Rights Fight; Jury Could Award Up to $600 Million (file photo)

Written by

in

A Clark County District Court judge has ruled that the State of Nevada took water rights away from the developers of Coyote Springs, the never-built master-planned city along U.S. 93 about an hour north of Las Vegas. The decision, issued Wednesday, sends the case to a jury that will decide how much the state owes, and that figure could reach as high as $600 million.

Key Takeaways

  • Judge Mark Denton sided with Coyote Springs Investment LLC (CSI), finding the state effectively took water rights it had previously awarded.
  • A jury will now decide the penalty, which could be as much as $600 million. Early estimates had put the state’s possible exposure as high as $2 billion before some claims were dismissed.
  • The suit names the Nevada Division of Water Resources, the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources and the State Engineer.
  • Coyote Springs was planned in the 1990s as a golf course community of 160,000 homes near the Clark-Lincoln county line.

What the judge decided

CSI argued that the state stripped away water rights it had already granted, while still requiring the developer to keep paying for them and prove the water was being put to good use. At the same time, the state made clear the water needed to build the community would never be approved. Judge Denton agreed.

In his ruling, Denton wrote that CSI had a reasonable, investment-backed expectation based on decades of rulings and conduct by the State Engineer, and that the engineer’s actions went beyond regulating the rights to effectively re-ordering and re-allocating them for the benefit of the public or other users.

Nevada courts have previously treated water rights as property, and taking property without compensation is not allowed. After narrowing the case to four of CSI’s claims, the judge moved it into its second phase, where a jury will set the amount.

How Coyote Springs got here

Early findings said 18,000 acre-feet of water was available, which gave the developer confidence the project could be built. The plan called for pumping 30,000 acre-feet from five underground basins. But the state later determined those basins were connected and had to be managed as one system, which changed the picture after the developer had already committed.

In a May 2018 letter, the State Engineer told CSI it would not sign off on the subdivision maps. In 2025, the Nevada Supreme Court upheld a decision cutting the development’s allotment to 8,000 acre-feet. To keep its water rights alive in the meantime, CSI has maintained a golf course at the site. The water rights had even been listed as collateral as the developer pulled together $150 million in financing.

The land is now owned by California developers Albert and Thomas Seeno. The lawsuit was filed in 2020, and the first phase of the trial began in July.

What it means for locals and visitors

Because the defendants are state agencies, any award would ultimately come from the state, which means Nevada taxpayers have a stake in what the jury decides. The case also highlights how tight water is in Southern Nevada: the dispute centers on whether a desert valley can support a brand-new city, and the state’s decision to manage connected groundwater basins as one system is a big part of the story.

Coming to Vegas? Practice craps, roulette, blackjack, baccarat and slots for free on our casino simulator before you play for real.

Sources

About the author

Read our editorial standards and corrections policy · send a tip or correction

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *